Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – Right for Me?

I would like to thank Nicolas, a connection on LinkedIn for todays article “brewing with electric pros and cons”. I was suffering from writer’s block, and asked online, for topic suggestions. Nicolas commented with the suggestions below:

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons - Nicolas

Today, we’re going to deep dive into brewing with electric, then we will look at direct fire and steam, bringing it all together with a round-up article and drawing some conclusions. It should make for a nice short series, and hopefully, be helpful to you.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – What Is Electric Heating

When brewing with electric, the heat is applied internally rather than externally (as with direct fire or steam jacket). The heating comes from electric elements which are housed in stainless steel sheathes inserted in your brewhouse vessels.

The main vessels in a brewhouse housing elements are the brew kettle and hot liquor tank (HLT). You can have electric heating for your mash tun too. However, that’s a little trickier requiring its own section.

Since, the elements are immersed in the liquid, virtually all of the energy applied to the elements, is transferred to heating your wort or water. Depending on the size of the brewhouse, you’ll usually have two to four elements per tank.

You can control the heating one of two ways:
  • Have an on/off switches for each element, turning them on and off when needed
  • Have a dedicated control panel to regulate percentage of output for each element for greater control or have set point for desired temperature.
Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons - Control Panel

Mashing with Electric Elements – Single Infusion

When brewing with electric, the cheapest option is, not having any form of heating for the mash tun. I’ve worked in several brewpubs configured this way. I’ve made good beer (well that’s what the patrons told me) with a single infusion mash.

With a single infusion mash you set the desired temperature, to “mash in” at. You then mash in at this temperature, and because the mash tun is fully insulated, it’ll not drop in too much in temperature during the mash stand (60 to 90 minutes).

Typically, the water (strike water) you mix with the malt is 10-15°F (5.5-8.3°C) above your desired mash temperature. So, if you want to mash in at 65°C, your strike water will be at 70-74°C. With modern modified malts, you’ll most likely get the gums and proteins needed with a single step infusion mash.

No, you can’t mash out, meaning raise the temperature after conversion of starch to sugars. However, as you’ll sparge with hotter water, around 78°C (172.5°F), it will raise the temperature of the grain bed slowly. So, your lauter run and efficiencies shouldn’t be affected too much.

Mashing with Electric Elements – Step Mashing

If you want to step mash however, then you’ll need to find a way to heat the mash tun. It’s possible to heat a mash with electric and there are two popular options:

HERMS (Heat Exchange Recirculating Mash Systems)

If you employ are HERMS system, the wort is circulated through a coil inside your HLT, with the temperature of the mash regulated by temperature of the water in the tank.

One advantage of this system is, it’s impossible to heat the mash above the temperature of the HLT. Thus, reducing the risk of overheating your mash and extracting bitter tannins.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons - HERMS System
Taken from a Home Brewing Thread – Click Here For Original Source

RIMS (Recirculating Infusion Mash Systems)

In a RIMS system, wort is recirculated by a pump over a heating element in a tube. The elements heat the wort, to raise the temperature to the desired set point when step mashing.

The advantage of this system is you don’t need to make adjustments to your HLT, to heat your mash. However, one disadvantage of RIMS is it’s not as efficient at heating your mash as HERMS.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – Mash Temperature Control

Whatever, electric heating system you employ for your mash tun, having precision control is recommended.

A typical control system includes temperature probs inserted into thermo-wells in a tank, proportional integral derivative controllers (PID’s) to set to the desired temperature and solid-state relays (SSR’s) to control the percentage output of each element.

Also, on your brewhouse control panel, it’s advisable to have variable speed control for your wort pump too. Plus, with a HERMS system, use your HLT pump, to recirculate the water in your tank to avoid stratification.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – The Kettle

Speaking of temperature control, you’ll need it for your brew kettle too. It’ll help avoid boil overs and allows you better control of the evaporation rate. Evaporation rate is typically 5 to 10 percent an hour when boiling your wort in the kettle.

If you know your input energy needed to reach boil, and achieve your desired evaporation rate, you can program the control panel to reach your targets batch after batch.

Wattage

The heat applied to the wort in the kettle, is determined by the overall wattage of your elements. The standard elements used in brewing are between 5,500 and 10,00 watts.

The type of elements used are “ultra-low density”, so as not to “scorch” the wort. So, the elements are configured to produce less heat per square inch.

Depending on your brew-length you can use between one and six elements in your kettle. As a guide you need around 40-45 watts per litre of beer in your kettle to get good heating. I took some figures from Brouland’s B-Tech Pro Brewing kettle range, as an example of watts needed. Here are the numbers:

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons - Kilowatts Needed for Kettle Size
Table to Show Average Watts Needed Per Brew-length Size

Now, kilowatts needed can vary depending on what type of electricity is being used. Is it single or three-phase, have you considered voltage too? Before you get too far choosing electric for your brewery, you need to check what’s the maximum electrical output the building you’ve chosen, can take.

It can get very expensive to upgrade, to achieve higher electrical output. It might mean, you can’t use the electric elements in the HLT, if you’re boiling wort in the kettle for example.

In every case; the needs, requirements and possibilities are different. If you’re unsure, then contact your local authority, to ask about the maximum electrical output for your building. If you’re renting, your landlord should have those figures for you.

Share these numbers with your preferred equipment manufacturer. They should be able to work with you to design a system, to fit your needs, within the limits of your buildings utility’s output.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – Start-up Costs

Electric and direct fire brewhouses, are around the same price for the tanks. Steam is generally more expensive, requiring extra jacketing plus steam generator costs.

Electrical elements are less expensive than most direct fire burners and obviously less expensive than a steam boiler. The control panels for an electric brewhouse vary in costs depending on your needs

If you choose a simple system, with LCD digital readouts and manual push button controls, your start up costs will be significantly cheaper than having a programmable touch screen.

Total costs when using electric for your control panel and venting will be similar to those of burner and boiler, plus venting and piping.

Availability

As we’ve touched on earlier in this article, you need to know the maximum electric output available for your building. In a brewery your electrical needs are wide ranging:

  • Brewhouse
  • Refrigeration
  • Lighting
  • Kitchen (if a brewpub)

There’s a lot of demand for the electric so, you need to figure out if your location is suitable. Breweries up to 3.5 barrels (around 400 litres) can work on either single or three-phase 208 or 240 requiring between 60 and 100 amps.

In the 7 to 10-barrel range (820 to 1,170 litres) you will need three-phase 208 service and 200 amps of power available. In most cases the upper limit, where electric heating is a viable solution, is 10 barrels.

25HL Brewhouse - On Platform 3
Bigger brewhouses aren’t conducive to using electric heating

I can’t comment on price of electricity in your region, as it varies widely from place to place. One thing to bear in mind however, which we mentioned earlier in the article, is elements are immersed in the liquid, making it efficient to heat wort and water.

When using direct fire, whether using burner below the kettle or a “flame-thrower” burner to heat a firebox, up to 40% of the heat produced isn’t transferred to the wort, but lost to the surrounding air.

One other ongoing cost to consider is, if there’s a “peak time” charge for using electric at certain times of the day/week.

Local Regulations and Codes

Depending on your location, electric maybe the way to go, especially if the area is mostly residential, where limits on steam boilers size usually exist. When using electric, the only real concern is venting the steam created in the brewing process.

With direct fire you need venting, for exhaust fumes from the burner plus your local authority might require a fire suppression system, if an open flame is visible.

There are usually strong protocols in place, concerning location and construction of rooms used to house a boiler for steam too. Furthermore, in certain locations there may be a limit to how big the boiler can be as well.

Safety and Climate Concerns

Compared to direct fire, electric offers less risk of fire, as there are no open flames. Furthermore, there’s little chance of electric shock, as long as the system has been wired and grounded correctly.

Also, because the elements are immersed, in the liquid for better heat transfer, you’re not heating up your brewhouse in the height of summer. Unlike with direct fire and associated heat loss, which can make your life uncomfortable.

Furthermore, the noise of a direct fire burner can be loud, unlike electric heating, which is quiet so, using electric is more “comfortable”, again.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons – Conclusions

Many people opt for electric heating because upfronts costs are cheaper. Plus, it’s easier to get to code, abiding by regulations set by your local authority. So, the path to opening is easier. As a heating source it’s efficient, with the energy use going directly to heat your liquids unlike direct fire.

The disadvantages are; in most regions, electric is expensive and you might pay even more at peak times. Furthermore, if you’ve a larger brewhouse, it might not be viable to use electric as your building can’t support the electric demand needed.

Brewing with Electric Pros and Cons - Electricity

However, if you’re on the small side, say 3.5 barrels (around 400 litres) electric might be best solution, as most buildings can support the needs for such a brewhouse.

Furthermore, if you’re brewpub, where space might be an issue, electric take up less space as there’s no boiler or firebox too.

However, if your brewery is above 10 barrels (around 1,200 litres), electric generally isn’t an option. As the power needed to be drawn is too much for the building to handle.

We will look into direct fire and steam as we continue our series on heating sources in brewing. Trying to reach some conclusions at the end of the series plus discussing, what might be best for you.

I hope you enjoyed our article “Brewing with electric pros and cons”. If you’ve any feedback, comments and/or experiences you want to share, please feel free to comment below or message me.

Who Am I?

My name is Neil, a British brewer based in China. I’ve brewed on a number of systems and completed several brewhouse installs, in various countries around the world, in my 25-year brewing career.

I now help people with their brewing projects, from sourcing brewing equipment from China to formulate recipes. If you’ve an upcoming brewing project and would like to discuss it, then please email me at:

neil@asianbeernetwork.com

Or you scan the QR codes below to add me to your preferred network (just let me know where you found the code).

I’m currently advising on projects from the UK to Tasmania. I can answer some initial questions you may have, or work on your project if assistance is needed.

For me information about my services please view the video below and/or you can download a PowerPoint presentation of my services here too.

Thanks for taking the time to read my article today, I hope you found it useful. Have a great day and happy brewing.

Cheers

Neil

Neil Playfoot

Neil is a brewer with 25 years international brewing experience. Based out of China (first came in 2010) he works as a brewing consultant helping brewers with their projects and brewing processes. To find out what services Neil can provide your brewery please click here. If you'd like to contact Neil you can email at neil@asianbeernetwork.com.
0 0 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments